Google Pixel 8a vs Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 Pro Max

Verdict

Google Pixel 8a and Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 Pro Max tie on the OH Rank at a score of 62. Google Pixel 8a wins on Screen and Main Camera; Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 Pro Max wins on Battery and IP Protection. Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 Pro Max is 5.6mm wider than Google Pixel 8a. Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 Pro Max is the more recent release, from Apr 28, 2026.

Score Breakdown

Category

Google Pixel 8a

72.7mm (2.86in) · May 2024 · Rank #167

Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 Pro Max

78.3mm (3.08in) · Apr 28, 2026 · Rank #161
Performance /15
5
5
Battery /15
6
14
Screen /15
13
11
IP Protection /15
12
15
Main Camera /15
15
6
Selfie /5
3
3
Video /5
3
3
SD Memory /5
0
0
Software /5
5
5
Desktop Replacement /5
0
0
TOTAL
62
62
Google Pixel 8a
72.7mm (2.86in) · May 2024 · Rank #167
5+6+13+12+15+3+3+0+5+0 = 62
Xiaomi Redmi Note 17 Pro Max
78.3mm (3.08in) · Apr 28, 2026 · Rank #161
5+14+11+15+6+3+3+0+5+0 = 62
* TOP Protection* TOP Battery EnduranceMidrange

EDITORIAL: Replacing the Redmi Note 15 Pro+, Xiaomi turned it's focus to phone's autonomy while making unexpected choices. The battery size improved significantly while ignoring the screen refresh rate improvment possibilities and dropping max brightness down to ~1100nits - seriously compromising sunlight visibility. To keep the phone in the same price segment, processor has been downgraded, main camera went from 200 to 50MP and nothing else was added to justify an upgrade.

PROs
okay SD 6 Gen 5 with UFS 4.1 (2.2 on 128GB version) performance, >42hr endurance from a huge 9200mAh (there is also a 10000mAh version!) battery with 60min 100W charging, IP69 with 3m drop protection, some good shots from a 50MP 26mm OIS PDAF main lens, stable HyperOS with up to 6 years of updates
CONs
230g despite plastic built, SD 6 Gen 5 power may not support promised years of OS updates, endurance should be record breaking for a battery this size, inefficient 1100nits 430ppi 120Hz AMOLED screen with Dolby Vision and minimal screen refresh flexibility, below average 8MP 15mm fixed focus ultrawide lens, no expandable memory, no desktop replacement functionality despite OS support for it, slow USB-C 2.0 port (with OTG)

Both phones here were scored by me, using the same ten categories, with no ads, sponsorships, or manufacturer relationships — this comparison is as objective and honest as it gets.

Visit Home page to compare world's best phones. You can see scoring and ranking explained on the About page.